Sleepy Hollow Real Estate Search

Sleepy Hollow Multi-Family Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for multi-family properties available in Sleepy Hollow and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Sleepy Hollow real estate market? Sign up for a  Sleepy Hollow Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Sleepy Hollow Multi-Family Homes for Sale

$1,199,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 1043442 MLS
Welcome to this exceptionally well-maintained, detached two-family Cape Cod home in the highly desirable Bay Terrace sector of Bayside. Situated on a generous 50 x 100 lot in R2A zoning, this move-in ready home features 1,182 sq. ft. of living space with the incredible advantage of 1,318 square feet of additional buildable space. The main level opens into an entry foyer with a coat closet before leading into the first floor unit. Inside, you're greeted by a spacious formal living room bathed in eastern light through a large triple window, a cozy dining room, a fully equipped U-shaped kitchen with direct rear access to the expansive backyard, a classic full bath naturally lit by an overhead skylight, a queen-size bedroom, and a primary king-size bedroom. Internal stairs take you down to the basement with high ceilings, laundry, and mechanicals with recently upgraded boiler and hot water systems. The basement is full and unfinished, offering a completely customizable blank canvas. The sunny stairwell topped with a bright skylight, leads to the upper unit; a fully equipped one-bedroom apartment featuring an open living and dining area, a full kitchen with standard appliances, and a bath with a stand-up shower. Outdoors, the property boasts a private driveway, a fully detached profile, and an enormous, tree-lined backyard complete with two storage sheds and a charming tucked-away pathway that leads directly up to the second shed. The home’s location is truly unbeatable for convenience and outdoor lifestyle. Just half a block from the Bay Terrace Shopping Center, you have endless retail, dining, movie theater entertainment, a fitness center, and a Stop & Shop right at your doorstep. Outstanding outdoor recreation surrounds you, starting less than five minutes away at historic Fort Totten Park, featuring scenic bike paths, running trails, sports fields, dog-friendly areas, a nearby golf course, and a scenic rock-edge pier perfect for watching the sunset. Nearby Crocheron Park offers dedicated pickleball courts, baseball and softball fields, a dog park, hiking trails, and picturesque views over Little Neck Bay. Alley Pond Park is also under 15 minutes away, providing expansive nature trails, athletic fields, and picnic areas. Daily conveniences and schooling are seamless, with the zoned elementary and middle schools under 5 minutes away, and Bayside High School and Queensborough Community College both under 10 minutes from the front door. Bell Boulevard is nearby for additional dining/shopping options, as well as transportation. The LIRR located at Bell Blvd / 28th Avenue provides a quick 30-minute ride into Manhattan, or East into Long Island. The Q28 and QM20 buses sit just two and a half blocks away from the home with direct access to Main Street Flushing. Cross Island Expwy and Clearview Expwy are also less than 5 minutes away. Whether you’re looking to occupy one unit and rent the other, secure a prime income property, or utilize the rare expansion upside, this property is an exceptional opportunity to invest in the highly desirable Bay Terrace area.

26-20 210th Place, Bayside

$1,830,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 1042960 MLS
Welcome to this magnificent, solid brick, semi-detached legal two-family home built in 2004, perfectly situated directly across from the scenic Kissena Park. Offering the ultimate blend of luxurious owner occupancy and high-earning rental potential, this sun-drenched, turn-key property has been extensively upgraded with fresh paint, brand-new flooring, updated kitchens, modern lighting, and mechanical improvements. Complete with gas cooking and heating, the home is fully separated for convenience and investment efficiency with two gas meters, three electricity meters. Unit A: The Luxurious Owner's Duplex (157th St Entrance) Designed with the grand scale of a single-family home, this stunning duplex boasts high ceilings and abundant natural light throughout. The first floor welcomes you with a spacious living room flowing seamlessly into a formal dining area, a modern open-concept kitchen featuring a brand-new range, range hood, and quartz countertops, and a convenient powder room. An interior door provides direct access to the lower level. Upstairs, the massive master bedroom suite serves as a private retreat, complete with a walk-in closet, a windowed full bathroom, and a private balcony overlooking serene park views. Two additional generously sized bedrooms feature excellent closet space, complemented by a pristine hallway full bathroom and a massive, dedicated storage room. Unit B: The Bright & Modern Apartment (Booth Memorial Ave Entrance) Featuring completely independent access, this unit is ideal for premium rental income or an extended guest suite. The layout offers a generous living room, a bright dining area, and an open-concept kitchen outfitted with a brand-new quartz countertop and range hood. The sizeable bedroom is flooded with natural light from dual exposures and is paired with a full bathroom. Fully Finished Lower Level: Boasting an independent outside entrance from Booth Memorial Avenue, the expansive, fully finished basement includes high ceilings and a half bath. This massive, open space offers endless versatility as a recreation room, home office, or media center. Prime Flushing Location: Enjoy effortless neighborhood living with Kissena Corridor Park right outside your door, offering immediate access to walking trails, scenic lakes, and open green spaces. This highly desirable location places everything you need within easy walking distance, including top-tier schools, Gold City Supermarket, local restaurants, bakeries, banks, and diverse shopping options. Commuters will love the dual parking spaces as well as the excellent neighborhood accessibility, with local buses just around the corner providing a quick and seamless connection into Downtown Flushing.

57-03 157th Street Unit #A & B, Flushing

$539,900
5 Beds 3 Baths 1042308 MLS
The best financial decision you make this year is going to look like a red barn on a hill. There are two full homes inside it. You take the upstairs. The lower unit has its own entrance, its own kitchen, its own laundry, and it goes to work on the mortgage while you go about your life. Your half is the one you fall for. The living room runs 40 feet and never meets a flat ceiling. It climbs into the roof, solid plank with the rafters left showing, a line of skylights down the whole length, and a brick fireplace on one wall. A walkway crosses above it on a black railing with the bedroom doors set along the wall behind. Three bedrooms and two baths sit up under the peak, and the timber follows you all the way up there. The rental is a 2 bedroom with a full bath, and it is nobody's afterthought. French doors open it straight onto the grass, so a tenant never sets foot in your part of the house. There is a real kitchen, a laundry of its own, and a 29 foot room with a brick hearth and a pellet stove. It is finished, it is bright, and it comes to you vacant, which means you write the first lease on your own terms. Everything that keeps a unit occupied out here is already in place: I-84 at Exit 4 minutes from the door, the station 15 minutes out, and the Minisink Valley district. What that buys you is not really money. It is the part of your income that stops being spoken for. The payment quits running your calendar. You take the week in October instead of talking yourself out of it. You get to be the person who bought 4.3 acres and a barn and still sleeps fine at night, because somebody downstairs is helping you hold it. And the land is why you were looking out here to begin with. Mowed ground runs from the back of the house down to a tree line and keeps going, a few fruit trees standing out in the open, deer along the edge most evenings, and not one other rooftop showing from any window. The wrap-around deck takes the afternoon sun. The screened porch beside it sits right up against the woods with a fan turning overhead, and it is the seat everybody fights over from May to September. Past the yard there is a fire ring for the nights it gets cold enough to want one. High Point is 20 minutes south, where the monument looks out over three states and Lake Marcia is worth the swim in August. The Appalachian Trail crosses at Unionville, where the hikers come off the ridge and land at Wit's End Tavern. The Delaware is close enough to be a Saturday rather than a trip, and every January the bald eagles come down and sit in the bare trees above the water. Route 97 takes the cliffs at Hawk's Nest for the days you feel like driving for its own sake. Dinner does not mean leaving the valley. Westtown Fare runs farm to table Thursday through Sunday. When you want the bigger night out, Milford is a short drive west over the river, where Broad Street has Bar Louis inside the Hotel Fauchere. Sunday is Warwick, the market in the South Street lot from 9 to 2 and the orchards picking through the fall. Manhattan is 75 miles southeast on the days you want it. The structure is settled and the land is here. The rest is paint and fixtures and the small choices that make it yours, which is the fun part if you have been waiting for a place worth putting your own hand on. The nights out by that fire ring are going to cost you a lot less than you think, and you are going to have a lot of them.

53 Woods Road, Port Jervis

$1,395,000
9 Beds 5 Baths 1043326 MLS
Presenting a newly constructed, contemporary three-unit residence situated in the prime Van Nest section of the Bronx. Engineered for both exceptional end-user comfort and high-yield investment performance, this turnkey asset delivers modern architecture, low-maintenance ownership, and robust income-producing potential. Interior Features & Layout Configuration: Three distinct residential units comprising a total of 9 generously proportioned bedrooms and 5 designer-finished bathrooms. Living Spaces: Open-concept layouts featuring seamless transitions between living and dining areas, optimized for natural light and effortless entertaining. Kitchens: Custom cabinetry, sleek countertops, modern fixtures, and ample storage capabilities. Systems & Efficiency: Updated mechanical systems, central heating and cooling, energy-efficient components, and convenient in-unit laundry provisions. Financial & Investment Highlights Income Potential: Estimated monthly rental income ranges from $3,500 to $3,850 per unit, yielding a potential gross monthly income between $10,500 and $11,550. Annual Projections: Projected annual gross revenue exceeding $138,000. Strategy: Ideal for an owner-occupant utilizing a live-in income model or an astute investor seeking a newly built, low-maintenance portfolio addition. Prime Location Strategically positioned in Van Nest with effortless access to major thoroughfares, public transit options, local retail, dining, parks, and schools, ensuring a convenient commute throughout the Bronx and into Manhattan. Professional representation and post-closing tenant-placement services available to ensure seamless transition and immediate cash flow optimization.

508 VAN NEST, Bronx

$1,395,000
9 Beds 5 Baths 1043305 MLS
Presenting a newly constructed, contemporary three-unit residence situated in the prime Van Nest section of the Bronx. Engineered for both exceptional end-user comfort and high-yield investment performance, this turnkey asset delivers modern architecture, low-maintenance ownership, and robust income-producing potential. Interior Features & Layout Configuration: Three distinct residential units comprising a total of 9 generously proportioned bedrooms and 5 designer-finished bathrooms. Living Spaces: Open-concept layouts featuring seamless transitions between living and dining areas, optimized for natural light and effortless entertaining. Kitchens: Custom cabinetry, sleek countertops, modern fixtures, and ample storage capabilities. Systems & Efficiency: Updated mechanical systems, central heating and cooling, energy-efficient components, and convenient in-unit laundry provisions. Financial & Investment Highlights Income Potential: Estimated monthly rental income ranges from $3,500 to $3,850 per unit, yielding a potential gross monthly income between $10,500 and $11,550. Annual Projections: Projected annual gross revenue exceeding $138,000. Strategy: Ideal for an owner-occupant utilizing a live-in income model or an astute investor seeking a newly built, low-maintenance portfolio addition. Prime Location Strategically positioned in Van Nest with effortless access to major thoroughfares, public transit options, local retail, dining, parks, and schools, ensuring a convenient commute throughout the Bronx and into Manhattan. Professional representation and post-closing tenant-placement services available to ensure seamless transition and immediate cash flow optimization.

506 VAN NEST, Bronx

$1,100,000
6 Beds 3 Baths 1043298 MLS
Welcome to 1405 East 233rd Street, Bronx, NY 10466! This impressive three-family brick residence offers an exceptional opportunity for both owner-occupants and investors seeking versatility, space, and income potential in the Edenwald section of the Bronx. The property features approximately 3,036 square feet of living space and is thoughtfully configured across three residential units. The home offers a spacious three-bedroom apartment on the top floor, a comfortable two-bedroom apartment on the second floor, and a versatile one-bedroom apartment on the first floor. Each unit provides generous living space, hardwood flooring, natural light, and functional layouts designed for comfortable everyday living. Additional features include a full finished basement with laundry and additional rooms, providing valuable supplemental space for recreation, storage, or other uses. The property also offers a private rear yard with a brick oven, creating an ideal setting for outdoor entertaining and family gatherings. Parking is a major bonus, with an attached garage and private driveway accommodating up to two vehicles. Conveniently located near local shopping, dining, schools, parks, and public transportation, including the Dyre Avenue subway station. With its multi-family configuration, substantial living space, private parking, outdoor space, and desirable Bronx location, 1405 East 233rd Street presents a rare opportunity to own a well-positioned income-producing property with tremendous potential. Whether you’re looking to live in one unit while generating rental income from the others or add a strong multi-family property to your portfolio, this property is one you won’t want to miss!

1405 E 233rd Street, Bronx

$1,595,000
6 Beds 2 Baths 1043177 MLS
Introducing an exceptional opportunity to own a truly turnkey, fully restored farmhouse-style two-family home in a prime Greenport Village location. 430 First Street features two meticulously updated residences, each offering three bedrooms, one full bathroom, and thoughtfully designed living spaces. The upper-level residence encompasses approximately 850 square feet and features soaring vaulted ceilings with decorative cross beams and an open-concept Great Room seamlessly connecting the kitchen, dining, and living areas. Three generously sized bedrooms, a full bathroom, and an in-unit washer and dryer complete the space. The main-level residence offers a similar layout with approximately 870 square feet of living space. Highlights include three bedrooms, one full bathroom, a spacious kitchen with vaulted ceilings, and separated living room, providing added flexibility and room to spread out. Outside, the property is equally impressive, with meticulously maintained landscaping, a newly installed crushed-stone driveway with Belgian block edging, a large rear lawn, full irrigation, and a charming front porch. A substantial 450-square-foot, two-car garage and additional storage shed further enhance the property's functionality. Whether you're an investor seeking a ready-made income-producing property or an end user looking to offset carrying costs with rental income, 430 First Street presents a compelling opportunity in the heart of Greenport Village. Located just two blocks from Greenport's vibrant business district, the property offers convenient access to public transportation, shops, restaurants, grocery stores, local farm stands, parks, and beaches—all while providing the space, condition, and versatility that make this a truly special offering.

430 1st Street, Greenport

$820,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 1043226 MLS
First time on the market! Welcome to this meticulously maintained two-family home nestled in one of the Bronx's most desirable and sought-after neighborhoods. This is a rare opportunity offering exceptional space, versatility, and convenience alike. Perfect for homeowners and investors. The main duplex unit is designed for comfortable living and entertaining. The first level features a welcoming entry, a convenient powder room, a spacious living room, and a bright dining area with a large sliding glass door that opens to a private backyard—perfect for gatherings, outdoor dining, or simply relaxing. Upstairs, you'll find three generously sized bedrooms, including a primary suite with its own half bath, a full hallway bathroom, and the added convenience of an in-unit washer and dryer. The second unit offers a private entrance and features an open-concept layout with two bedrooms and one full bathroom, making it ideal for generating rental income, accommodating extended family, or hosting guests. Additional highlights include a one-car garage, a private driveway, and a roof that is only one year old, providing added value and peace of mind. Perfectly situated for commuters, this home is just minutes from the #5 subway line, express bus service to Manhattan, and I-95, making travel throughout the city and beyond effortless. Enjoy easy access to shopping, dining, and entertainment at the mall at Bay Plaza, along with nearby parks, schools, and everyday conveniences. Whether you're searching for a spacious primary residence with income-producing potential or a smart investment opportunity, this exceptional property truly has it all. Don't miss your chance to own this gem in one of the Bronx's most coveted neighborhoods! HOUSE WILL BE DELIVERED COMPLETLEY VACANT UPON CLOSING!

3605 Boller Avenue, Bronx

$625,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 1042859 MLS
Welcome to 58 Palmer Road in Yonkers, a classic semi-attached two-family home in the desirable Bryn Mawr (Bryn Mawr Park) neighborhood that is truly a diamond in the rough. This is a major opportunity for the right buyer or investor who has vision and is ready to put in the TLC—because while the property needs a significant amount of work, it has been priced accordingly and sits in a prime, high-demand location. The layout offers excellent flexibility. The main level features a spacious four-bedroom, two-bath duplex that opens onto a porch and leads out to a very spacious, long backyard—ideal for outdoor living, entertaining, or future enhancement once renovated. Below is a convenient ground-floor one-bedroom, one-bath walk-in unit with its own entrance. Together, the configuration supports living in one unit while collecting rent from the other, or operating the entire property as a pure investment after renovations. Location is a standout strength. Palmer Road sits right by major highways, with immediate access via the Saw Mill River Parkway (Exit 5A at Palmer Road) and quick connections to I-87 (the New York State Thruway/Major Deegan), the Cross County Parkway, and other routes. This makes commuting into Manhattan or around Westchester straightforward. The Bryn Mawr area itself is an established residential neighborhood with a mix of single- and multi-family homes, nearby green spaces including Welty Park, access toward Tibbetts Brook Park and the South County Trailway, local shopping and services, and proximity to well-regarded schools such as Saunders Trades & Technical High School (located on Palmer Road). The combination of convenience, parks, and everyday amenities keeps demand strong in this part of Yonkers. This is not a turnkey property—it will require meaningful renovation and a clear vision. But for the buyer or investor prepared to put in the work, the upside is clear: renovate, then either occupy one unit and generate rental income from the other, or hold it fully as an income-producing asset in a location that supports long-term value. Priced to reflect its current condition, 58 Palmer Road represents a genuine opportunity for someone ready to unlock its potential.

58 Palmer Road, Yonkers

$799,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 1040409 MLS
Welcome to this wonderful, two-family home in a highly desirable area of Yonkers, offering an excellent opportunity for multi-generational living, extended family, or an owner-occupied looking for additional income potential. The main apartment features three bedrooms and one full bath, along with a spacious living room and a comfortable "dine-in" kitchen, which opens to a side patio for entertaining "al-fresco." Gleaming hardwood floors. The "walk-up" attic provides additional storage space with potential to be finished and customized to suit your needs. The second apartment, on the garden level, offers a private and inviting one-bedroom layout, complete with an eat-in-kitchen, living room and charming fireplace. This apartment also enjoys access to garden living with patio and green space for the outdoor enthusiast, creating a pleasant setting for relaxing, playing or just enjoying. Updates include roof, renovated shed, new refrigerator, and more. Additional highlights include a new bluestone pathway with private driveway, accommodating up to four cars, a valuable convenience in Yonkers. Located close to shopping, schools, houses of worship, restaurants, casual and fine dining and countless everyday errands right at your fingertips. Yonkers, famously knows as "Hollywood on the Hudson" continues to experience exciting growth and revitilization, particularly throughout its downtown area, making it an increasingly desirable place to live, invest and call "home." Don't miss this opportunity!!!

201 Bennett Avenue, Yonkers

$849,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 1037629 MLS
Own, live and/or potentially work in an important building from Newburgh's grand historical past! 98 Grand was built in the 1870s for a prominent member of the community with old newspaper clippings reporting fabulous soirees in the front parlor with mandolins, banjos and piano recitals. It was modified in the 1890s by the Newburgh Board of Education to include a staircase to the original Newburgh Library next door which still exists! albeit as a bookcase now. The unusual and extraordinary front window likely also dates from the 1890s as does the magnificent front parlor. Modernized and beautifully updated over the years that followed, 98 is now a well maintained solid brick 4 unit building with 2 x 1 bed apts on the 2nd and 3rd floors with Hudson River views from their kitchens and bathrooms along with a convenient coin operated washer dryer on the 2nd floor. On the first floor there is a gorgeous spacious 2 bed apartment which still tells the story of its parlor days with its open plan space and original front window intact. The lower level with a separate entrance has recently been updated with a brand new HVAC system creating an inviting large 1000 sq ft office space with separate shower and bathroom overlooking an internal courtyard. This private space could potentially be developed further to become a live/work space being ideally situated in this prime position on Grand St in the first few blocks off Broadway. Located a few doors up the road from the Masonic Hall currently being repurposed as an upscale Hotel and Spa with a rooftop martini lounge overlooking the Hudson, as well as being walking distance from all the cafes, restaurants, bars and art galleries on Liberty St and Broadway AND riverfront dining on the Hudson River below! 98 grand is an ideal opportunity to own a piece of Newburgh's history while also becoming a part of its present day renaissance.

98 Grand Street, Newburgh

$1,150,000
7 Beds 4 Baths 1042536 MLS
Welcome to 2 Kiely Place, a recently updated corner property offering a rare combination of residential space, income potential, commercial-use potential, private parking, and flexibility. The property is classified as Building Class S2 — primarily a two-family property with one store or office — creating an especially compelling opportunity for investors, business owners, or buyers looking to combine residential and commercial potential. The upper level, originally configured with four bedrooms and a living room, is currently being utilized as five bedrooms. The first-floor residence is currently configured with three bedrooms plus a living room. The property features a total of four bathrooms and generous space throughout. The finished basement has a separate entrance and includes multiple additional rooms, providing valuable bonus space and additional possibilities, subject to permitted use. Outside, the property features a detached garage, another additional parking for another vehicle, and a separate space currently used for motorcycle parking. With the property’s S2 mixed-use classification, buyers can explore the commercial possibilities available for the property, including potential store or office use, subject to applicable zoning, DOB requirements, and permitted use. The current owner recently completed numerous updates throughout the property with the intention of holding it long-term, but a decision to relocate now presents an opportunity for the next owner. Whether purchased as an income-producing investment, an owner-occupied property with rental income, or a residential and commercial opportunity, 2 Kiely Place offers tremendous versatility.

2 Kiely Place, Brooklyn

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.