Sleepy Hollow Real Estate Search

Sleepy Hollow Multi-Family Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for multi-family properties available in Sleepy Hollow and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Sleepy Hollow real estate market? Sign up for a  Sleepy Hollow Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Sleepy Hollow Multi-Family Homes for Sale

$900,000
5 Beds 2 Baths 1020558 MLS
Charming Renaissance Revival Home in the Manida Street Historic District – 861 Manida Street, Bronx, NY Step into a piece of New York history at 861 Manida Street, located in the highly regarded Manida Street Historic District. Designed by noted architect James F. Meehan and completed in 1909, this residence showcases timeless Renaissance Revival architecture with distinctive Flemish Revival elements. The property is further distinguished by its location on a street co-named in honor of the late Cybeale Ross, adding a meaningful layer of community recognition and local history. Key Features: Architectural Detail: Classic Renaissance Revival design featuring rounded projecting bays, symmetrical facades, and refined classical ornamentation throughout. Flemish Revival Elements: Decorative parapets and unique roofline details create a striking European-inspired presence. Historic Character: Original stained glass accents, low stone stoops, and period details reflect early 20th-century craftsmanship and charm. Endless Potential: Well-maintained and full of original character, offering a rare opportunity to customize while preserving its historic integrity. Prime Location: Situated in the Manida Street Historic District, close to local shops, dining, and transportation. A neighborhood known for its architectural significance and community appeal. This is a rare opportunity to own a distinctive historic home blending old-world elegance with modern-day potential. Seller motivated - Basement has (3) OSE Offered at $990,000 – Schedule your private showing today.

861 Manida Street, Bronx

$949,000
6 Beds 4 Baths 1018117 MLS
Exceptional opportunity to own a spacious, income-producing two-family corner property in the heart of East New York. Situated on a 20' x 100' gated lot, this well-maintained home offers approximately 2,400 square feet of interior living space thanks to a legal first-floor extension, along with private parking for two vehicles and off-street parking. The owner's duplex occupies the first floor and features an inviting open front porch, four generously sized bedrooms, two full bathrooms, an in-unit laundry area, and an expansive layout designed for comfortable everyday living and entertaining. The second-floor apartment has been tastefully renovated and offers two bedrooms and one full bathroom. Currently rented on a month-to-month basis for $1,900 per month, it provides immediate rental income while offering flexibility for future occupancy or investment plans. The fully finished basement has its own private entrance and adds valuable bonus space with two recreation rooms, a full bathroom, and a separate boiler room—ideal for extended living, a home office, gym, or additional entertainment space. Additional highlights include gas hot water heating, a main roof approximately seven years old, a newer roof over the first-floor extension completed just three years ago, and a secure gated exterior with off-street parking. Conveniently located near shopping, neighborhood restaurants, parks, schools, and public transportation, including nearby subway and bus lines, the property offers easy access throughout Brooklyn and into Manhattan. The surrounding neighborhood continues to benefit from ongoing residential investment while maintaining the convenience and accessibility that make Brooklyn living so desirable. Whether you're looking for a spacious primary residence with rental income or a strong investment opportunity, this versatile property is one you won't want to miss. Home is being sold with 2nd floor tenant adding immediate income of $1,900/month, no lease.

708 Snediker Avenue, Brooklyn

$799,000
7 Beds 5 Baths 1020091 MLS
More than a multifamily, this is a waterfront compound where home, hospitality, and investment naturally come together on the shores of electric motorboat-friendly Lake Huntington. The property offers four residences, sweeping lake views from every unit, direct water access, a three-car garage, and generous off-street parking. Occupying the entire top floor, the newly renovated 2,500-square-foot penthouse lives with the scale, privacy, and presence of a standalone lake house. An expansive wall of windows fills the open-concept living spaces with natural light, framing panoramic views across the water. The beautifully appointed kitchen features waterfall stone countertops, brand-new stainless steel appliances, and generous space for gathering, while a custom wet bar makes entertaining effortless. The thoughtfully designed layout includes three bedrooms and two full baths, highlighted by a spacious primary suite with a soaking tub, where each morning begins with the sunrise over the lake. The penthouse also enjoys air conditioning and direct access to a walk-up attic. On the main level, two one-bedroom apartments each enjoy private decks, direct access to the waterfront, and uninterrupted lake views. One has been thoughtfully renovated with new flooring, updated kitchen with a brand-new appliance package and updated bath. While the second offers a charming, well-maintained kitchen full of character. Together, they provide remarkable flexibility - whether welcoming family and friends, generating additional income, or embracing a lifestyle where home, hospitality, and investment come together naturally. The lower-level apartment is occupied by a dependable long-term tenant, providing immediate rental income. Every residence enjoys sweeping lake views, dock access, washer and dryer hookups, updated mechanicals and hot water heaters. Across the street, a three-car garage and expansive driveway provide exceptional off-street parking - an uncommon amenity for a waterfront property. Whether shared across generations, enjoyed as a private retreat with built-in income, or held as a long-term investment, this is a place to gather, host, invest and invites you to shape it around the life you want to live. All under 2 hrs from the GWB and just 15 mins to Bethel Woods, Calicoon, Narrowsburg and even less to the ever popular Cohecton Pump House and stunning Delaware River.

6641 Narrowsburg Road, Lake Huntington

$1,199,999
6 Beds 4 Baths 1019709 MLS
Welcome to 172-40 125th Avenue, an exceptional brick two-unit residence ideally situated in the heart of Jamaica, just off Merrick Boulevard and Baisley Boulevard. Offering an outstanding combination of space, versatility, and convenience, this beautifully renovated property is an excellent opportunity for both owner-occupants and investors alike. Each unit features a spacious layout with 3 generously sized bedrooms, creating a total of 6 bedrooms and 4 full bathrooms throughout the home. Completely updated from top to bottom, the residence showcases modern finishes throughout, including gleaming hardwood floors, new windows, and stylishly renovated bathrooms. The kitchens have been thoughtfully designed with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and a center island, creating the perfect space for cooking, dining, and entertaining. Bright and inviting living spaces, functional floor plans, and ample room for comfortable everyday living make this property a standout in today's market. The full finished basement provides an abundance of additional living space, perfect for a recreation area, home office, gym, media room, or guest quarters. Whether you're looking for extra room to spread out or additional flexibility, this lower level offers endless potential. Conveniently located near shopping, restaurants, schools, parks, public transportation, JFK Airport, and major highways including the Belt Parkway and Van Wyck Expressway, this location offers easy access to everything Queens has to offer while maintaining the feel of a quiet residential neighborhood.

17240 125th Avenue, Jamaica

$1,079,999
6 Beds 2 Baths 1019947 MLS
Whether you're seeking a sophisticated primary residence with supplemental income or a valuable addition to your investment portfolio, this remarkable property offers the perfect blend of luxury, flexibility, and long-term value. Welcome to this beautifully appointed two family where classic Brooklyn charm meets modern luxury. Nestled on a tree-lined block in the desirable Canarsie neighborhood, this elegant residence offers spacious living, timeless architectural character, and the comfort today's buyers demand. 102-24 Avenue K is a meticulously renovated 100% brick, corner property two family that will captivate you from the moment you arrive with its warm & welcoming energy. Sitting on a 30x100 CORNER Lot, featuring a wide private driveway with garage access from the front, with additional parking options at the side of the yard and the back driveway. With its unique setup this is the perfect opportunity for buyers with large or multiple vehicles. Offering two, 3 bedroom 1 bath units. Both units enjoy modern, open concept living/dining areas which provide great space for entertaining. Beautiful chefs granite kitchens equipped with floor to ceiling custom cabinetry and adorned with a full fleet of stainless steel appliances. Well proportioned bedrooms with ample closet space. Fully tiled bathrooms that boast state of the art wall & floor tiles and adorned with spa like finishes. Renovations include brand new select wide oak wood flooring, Acoustic designer wall panels, LED lighting, energy efficient split unit systems and much more! Must see to appreciate. This exceptional townhouse presents a rare opportunity to own a piece of Brooklyn while enjoying the space, privacy, and lifestyle the neighborhood has to offer. Conveniently located with close proximity to major transportation which makes commuting a breeze. Just off Rockaway Parkway, Flatlands Avenue, Seaview Avenue. Short blocks to schools, shopping centers, restaurants, cafes, parks, and many other vibrant neighborhood amenities. Quick, easy, access to JFK Airport, Resorts World Casino. Schedule your private showing today to be among the first to experience this exceptional opportunity, and grab your chance to be apart of the Canarsie Vibe.

10224 Avenue K, Brooklyn

$1,800,000
4 Beds 5 Baths 1016354 MLS
Welcome to 83A Cooper Street, a newly completed, fully gut-renovated luxury multifamily property located in the heart of East Brooklyn. Designed with modern living in mind, this exceptional residence offers flexible layouts, premium finishes, and valuable R6 zoning, making it an ideal opportunity for investors, end-users, or multigenerational living. The garden-level duplex features a spacious one-bedroom layout with a contemporary kitchen, full bathroom, and comfortable living area. The lower level expands the living space with an additional full bathroom and a versatile recreation area that can be utilized as a home office, media room, gym, guest suite, or additional sleeping quarters. The first-floor residence offers a bright and airy one-bedroom layout complete with an open-concept kitchen, living area, and full bathroom. Thoughtfully designed with modern finishes and abundant natural light, this unit provides both comfort and functionality. The top-floor residence features two generously sized bedrooms and two full bathrooms, creating a spacious and private living environment. A dedicated staircase leads to a beautifully developed rooftop deck, offering an ideal setting for entertaining, relaxing, dining al fresco, or enjoying panoramic neighborhood views. Property highlights include: • Newly completed gut renovation from top to bottom • Three thoughtfully designed residential levels plus finished lower level • Modern kitchens and designer bathrooms • Private rooftop deck access • Flexible living arrangements for owner-occupants or investors • R6 zoning with future development potential (buyers should verify independently) • Excellent transportation, shopping, dining, and neighborhood amenities nearby A rare opportunity to acquire a turnkey luxury multifamily property with modern construction quality, flexible layouts, and long-term upside in one of Brooklyn's rapidly evolving neighborhoods.

83A Cooper Street, Brooklyn

$2,200,000
8 Beds 5 Baths 1012493 MLS
Prime Investment & Income-Producing Opportunity in East Quogue Discover a rare and versatile multi-residence compound in the heart of East Quogue, offering exceptional investment potential and a proven history of rental income. Whether you're seeking a lucrative income-producing property, a private retreat, or a combination of both, this unique offering presents endless possibilities. The centerpiece of the property is a charming farmhouse, once a popular Bed and Breakfast from the 1900's, "The Morgan Tourister". Filled with generous living space, the home comfortably accommodates you and your guests, featuring five bedrooms, living room, formal dining room, spacious eat-in country kitchen, den, and expansive outdoor areas. Unwind and enjoy peaceful afternoons on the inviting wraparound porch overlooking the property's beautiful grounds. Complementing the main residence are two separate one-bedroom cottages and an attached studio, each with its own private yard area, providing ideal accommodations for guests and tenants. Rental permits are already in place, making this a turnkey opportunity for immediate income generation. The grounds offer ample parking, abundant outdoor entertaining areas, and room for a pool, creating even more opportunities to enhance and personalize the estate. Bordering a picturesque 35-acre tree farm and ideally situated on the Quogue border, this desirable location is just moments from East Quogue's charming shops, restaurants, ocean beaches, train service, Hampton Jitney stops, and less than two hours from New York City. A truly unique opportunity to own a multi-residence compound with established rental history, bordering beautiful open space, in one of the Hamptons most sought-after locations.

718 Montauk Highway, E. Quogue

$1,400,000
7 Beds 2 Baths 1009289 MLS
Exceptional development opportunity in the vibrant heart of Fordham, Bronx. This 2-family residence, built in 1920, sits on a 3,924 sq ft lot with 3,696 sq ft of building space. The property's R6 zoning designation unlocks significant development potential for residential expansion and redevelopment. **Welcome to Fordham – Where Community Thrives** Fordham is a dynamic, welcoming neighborhood that pulses with authentic energy and cultural richness. Anchored by historic Fordham University, this beloved community features tree-lined streets, charming pre-war brownstones, and a wonderful mix of architectural character. The neighborhood radiates with life – from diverse local restaurants and shops along the bustling Fordham Road corridor to the natural beauty of the NY Botanical Garden and Bronx Zoo nearby. What makes Fordham special is its strong sense of community. Year-round festivals, cultural celebrations, and neighborhood institutions create a warm, inclusive atmosphere where families, young professionals, and longtime residents thrive together. The area is experiencing exciting growth – projected to add nearly 1,000 new households over the next 5 years – signaling strong confidence in the neighborhood's future. **Smart Investment Fundamentals:** The numbers back up the neighborhood's appeal. With a robust rental market (median rent $1,384/month), 97% renter-occupied housing, and steady population growth of 4.5% over 5 years, this is a neighborhood on the rise. Strategic location near major employers, universities, and attractions ensures consistent demand. **Development Highlights:** • R6 Zoning - Maximum development flexibility and residential potential • Strong Rental Market - Proven demand with 97% renter-occupied housing • Population Growth - 4.5% projected 5-year increase to 62,682 residents • Vibrant Community - Cultural diversity, local businesses, and strong institutions • Strategic Location - Near Fordham University, NY Botanical Garden, Bronx Zoo • 3,924 sq ft Lot - Excellent for redevelopment and expansion Perfect for developers, investors, and builders seeking strategic growth opportunities in a thriving, welcoming community. This property represents a compelling entry point for residential development in Fordham's vibrant and rapidly appreciating market.

2540 Davidson Avenue, Bronx

$1,500,000
1009747 MLS
DEVELOPMENT FUNDAMENTALS This 5,890 sq ft corner lot represents a rare redevelopment opportunity in one of the Bronx’s highest-density, most transit-accessible corridors. The existing 3-family building (3,614 sq ft) sits on a substantially underbuilt lot. Under current zoning, the site supports FAR 2.43, enabling approximately 14,313 sq ft of buildable area—creating 10,699 sq ft of additional development capacity above the existing structure. MARKET FUNDAMENTALS & RENTAL DEMAND The Fordham submarket demonstrates exceptional rental strength: 97.25% renter-occupied units, median rent of $1,365/month, and 19,033 households within the immediate neighborhood. This persistent demand supports stable income during any hold period and provides downside protection during repositioning phases. The area maintains 100,957 persons per sq mi density—among the highest in New York City. STRATEGIC LOCATION & TRANSIT ACCESS 2532 Davidson Avenue anchors a major commercial and employment hub with 1,257 establishments, multiple subway lines (2, 4, 5, D trains), and proximity to Fordham University, the New York Botanical Garden, and the Bronx Zoo. The location benefits from consistent foot traffic, institutional employment, and tourism-driven activity, supporting both residential and mixed-use development strategies. REDEVELOPMENT POTENTIAL The property’s underutilized zoning envelope creates a clear path for value creation through expansion, repositioning, or ground-up redevelopment. Current income from the 3-family building provides cash flow during acquisition, planning, and entitlement phases, enhancing project feasibility. INVESTMENT THESIS Strong rental demand, high neighborhood density, strategic transit access, and significant unused development capacity position this site for meaningful upside. The Bronx rental market continues to show supply constraints and persistent demand, making this property an attractive opportunity for developers seeking scalable Bronx exposure with a straightforward path to value.

2532 Davidson Avenue, Bronx

$1,050,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 1018632 MLS
**LEGAL 2-FAMILY | APPROX. 3,657 SQ. FT. | BRICK | GARAGE + PARKING | FULL BASEMENT | PRIME BRONX OPPORTUNITY** Welcome to **1120 Anderson Avenue**, an impressive legal two-family offering approximately **3,657 square feet of space, flexibility and income-producing potential** in the heart of the Bronx. Whether you're looking for a **primary residence with rental income, a multi-generational home, or your next investment property**, this well-maintained property delivers the space and versatility today's buyers are searching for. Featuring **6 bedrooms**, generous living areas and a **full basement**, this home provides multiple possibilities for comfortable living and long-term ownership. Separate utilities add convenience for a two-family property, while the **garage and additional parking** provide a valuable advantage in New York City. **LIVE IN ONE UNIT AND RENT THE OTHER.** Build equity while having the potential benefit of rental income helping offset your monthly housing expenses. Investors will appreciate the property's substantial square footage, legal two-family status, location and long-term income potential. Conveniently situated near the **4, B and D trains**, public transportation, major roadways, shopping, schools, neighborhood amenities and Yankee Stadium, the location provides excellent accessibility throughout the Bronx and into Manhattan. ### WHY 1120 ANDERSON AVENUE? **? Legal 2-Family** **? Approx. 3,657 Sq. Ft.** **? 6 Bedrooms** **? Full Basement** **? Separate Utilities** **? Brick Construction** **? Garage + Parking** **? Excellent Owner-Occupant or Investment Opportunity** **? Convenient Access to Manhattan** **SPACE. INCOME POTENTIAL. LOCATION. OPPORTUNITY.** Properties offering this combination of size, two-family use, parking and accessibility are increasingly difficult to find. **Seller is motivated and ready to make a deal. Bring your buyers and your best offer.** Schedule your private showing today and discover everything **1120 Anderson Avenue** has to offer.

1120 Anderson Avenue, Bronx

$795,000
1018444 MLS
The Arlington House Circa 1864. As this nation was making its way out of The CIvil War, tourists began making their way to the Catskill Mountains. The hamlet of Palenville, in the town of Catskill, NY is home to the country's first Art Colony. The Hudson River School of painters helped lead that movement to the magic of Upstate that continues today. The Arlington House has been through a few different iterations over its lifespan, but has consistently operated as a boarding house, hotel and residence since its inception. It is rumoured that Mark Twain and his family spent the night here on the way to their legendary summer vacation right up the road in Onteora Park. The current owner grew up in the house and they enjoyed the contribution of the rental apartments. When he took control, he performed a full gut renovation of the main house in 2011 and the apartment building in 2023. There is all new drywall, insulation, plumbing and electric. As well as a new wrap around porch, roof and box gutters. The house was primarily used as a short term rental after the renovation, hosting small weddings, group gatherings and ski trips. The main house has 5 bedrooms and 3 baths, a large open floor plan and parlour that lend themselves to entertaining large groups. There is also a 3rd floor walk up attic that was originally a living space years ago. That has been gutted with electric and plumbing roughed in as the owner was going to finish that as a private space for himself. The separate apartment building has 3 one bedroom units. Two of them are complete and the third unit is ready for you to finish with brand new kitchen cabinets in the boxes and onsite. There is also another space that has electric and plumbing roughed in. It could be used to join to the other downstairs unit, make a laundry room and storage or create a 5th unit with proper permitting from the town. This amazing historic home looks up at the mountains through the Kaaterskill Clove. Surrounded by skiing, hiking, swimming in the nearby creeks, Kaaterskill Falls and North Lake. Only 10 minutes from the villages of Catskill and Saugerties and 20 minutes to Hudson,Amtrak and Woodstock. Palenville is home to the Rip Van Winkle Golf Course, the Circle W Cafe and General Store and The Griffin House, recently taken over by the previous management of Tavern on the Green. The Griffin house is a great pub with small festivals in their beautiful outdoor space overlooking the creek. A bed and breakfast or inn would be a great addition to the town. The Arlington House lends itself to whatever you envision whether it's a single family home with ADU units or strictly an investment property. It has a proven track record as an earner with financials available Cap rate of 6 with potential for 8 with the completion of the 4th unit. Advance notice needed and agent must accompany. Book your showing today.

3361 Rt-23A, Palenville

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.