Sleepy Hollow Real Estate Search

Sleepy Hollow Properties between $400,000 and $450,000 for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400,000 and $450,000 properties available in Sleepy Hollow and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Sleepy Hollow real estate market? Sign up for a  Sleepy Hollow Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Sleepy Hollow Properties between $400,000 and $450,000 for Sale

$425,000
5 Beds 4 Baths 954384 MLS
2 HOMES. ONE PROPERTY on 6.5 acres in the heart of Glen Spey! This versatile property features two attached residences ideal for multi-generational living, rental income, or extended guests. This isnt your typical single family home. The primary residence offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a spacious living room, country kitchen, and dining area with sliders leading to a large deck perfect for entertaining and enjoying the peaceful setting. The second residence includes 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths, living room, dining area, and country kitchen. The homes are connected by a single adjoining door for added convenience. Approximately 2,096 sq ft of main-level living space, plus a full unfinished basement offering excellent potential for future expansion. Each residence has separate entrances, heating systems, basements, and laundry, while sharing one electric meter, whole-house generator (recently serviced), and central air. Additional highlights include a 10 year roof, paved circular driveway, ample storage, and total privacy. Located just minutes from the Delaware River, this area is known for rafting, kayaking, fishing, and hiking with nearby access to state land and scenic trails. Enjoy concerts and cultural events at the legendary Bethel Woods Center for the Arts, plus nearby casinos, wineries, and charming river towns, Convenient access to commuter trains and buses to NYC makes this an ideal full-time residence or weekend retreat. Live in one side and rent the other, or enjoy the entire home as one expansive residence, an exceptional opportunity with endless possibilities. This is a perfect situation that you don't want to miss out on.

70 Okeechobee Road, Glen Spey

$409,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 948942 MLS
Welcome to Holbrow House at 46 Union Street, a lovingly maintained and updated 1818 home in the quaint Village of Montgomery. As soon as you enter, you're greeted by the warmth of the historic wide plank wood floors and rooms filled with natural light. The main living area offers great flexibility with an additional room that can be used as an office, den or guest space. Charming details throughout the home include French doors, solid bluestone windowsills, and a restored working gas fireplace. The kitchen blends old and new, with newer stainless steel appliances, while highlighting the original stone foundation and historic doors. An attached utility room has a dedicated space for your washer and dryer. Upstairs, the primary bedroom features vaulted ceilings, along with a second bedroom and another bonus space that can adapt to your needs. Outside, the fenced-in yard feels private and inviting, with mature trees, established plantings and seasonal flowers. A shed provides convenient storage for gardening tools and outdoor equipment. Located just moments from Montgomery's shops, coffee houses, restaurants, pickleball, tennis and basketball courts, baseball fields, hiking trails and access to the Wallkill River. This home offers the best of village living in a truly special setting. 11 minute drive to Campbell Hall Train Station; 22 minute drive to Beacon Train Station; 90 minute train ride to NYC. You will not want to miss this special home.

46 Union Street, Montgomery

$449,900
6 Beds 2 Baths 959162 MLS
Perched upon a corner lot knoll in the center of the hamlet of Arkville in Delaware County, this stately historic building awaits its next use. Boasting almost 8,000 square feet on three levels, situated on just over an acre with endless possibilities. A portion of this building dates back to the 1700s with additions and renovations in the 1900's and had been used as a tavern, boarding house, apartments and its most current use as the home of the Catskill Center for Conservation and Development. It is within a BC; Business Commercial zoning district which allows for many possible uses including a conversion to single family home/residential use. Presently there is a series of well appointed offices as well as a welcoming lobby, dining hall with kitchen, filing/storage room and restrooms on the first and second floors. The third floor is filled with natural light and some larger spaces as well as a partially unfinished section with four more possible rooms. Beautiful molding throughout as well as wide plank wood flooring. The surrounding properties include the Delaware and Ulster heritage railroad, just across the street as well as several shops, a distillery and eateries. The Village of Margaretville is just 1 mile to the west and offers a variety of amenities. Belleayre Ski Lodge is just 10 minutes to the east (+/-7miles). The property is serviced by municipal water and sewer. There is a +/-650 square foot detached outbuilding electric and plumbing with an array of solar panels that service the property.

43355 State Route 28, Arkville

$449,900
956072 MLS
Perched upon a corner lot knoll in the center of the hamlet of Arkville in Delaware County, this stately historic building awaits its next use. Boasting almost 8,000 square feet on three levels, situated on just over an acre with endless possibilities. A portion of this building dates back to the 1700s with additions and renovations in the 1900's and had been used as a tavern, boarding house, apartments and its most current use as the home of the Catskill Center for Conservation and Development. It is within a BC; Business Commercial zoning district which allows for many possible uses including a conversion to single family home/residential use. Presently there is a series of well appointed offices as well as a welcoming lobby, dining hall with kitchen, filing/storage room and restrooms on the first and second floors. The third floor is filled with natural light and some larger spaces as well as a partially unfinished section with four more possible rooms. Beautiful molding throughout as well as wide plank wood flooring. The surrounding properties include the Delaware and Ulster heritage railroad, just across the street as well as several shops, a distillery and eateries. The Village of Margaretville is just 1 mile to the west and offers a variety of amenities. Belleayre Ski Lodge is just 10 minutes to the east (+/-7miles). The property is serviced by municipal water and sewer. There is a +/-650 square foot detached outbuilding electric and plumbing with an array of solar panels that service the property.

43355 State Route 28, Arkville

$418,000
1 Beds 1 Baths 953380 MLS
*improved price* GREAT NECK PLAZA - Welcome to The Carleton, a boutique accessible co-op building which situated in a most desirable section of Great Neck // Enter a modern Lobby where you take the elevator up one flight to the first, elevated residential floor // It's on this sleekly designed level you'll find #1L, which offers the inviting charm of a comfortable home which is flooded by natural sunlight // This bright South facing front + corner unit, has been lovingly updated featuring a recently gut renovated kitchen + bath, refinished hardwood floors, new base mouldings + recessed lighting // Paint by Benjamin Moore, water fixtures by Moen // A most desirable feature is the Balcony which can offer a spot for fresh air relaxation highlighted by a wide open tree lined view // The spacious Eat-In Kitchen features a coffee bar area + window by the sink, for another open sunny view // Kitchen Appliances by the high-end Frigidaire Gallery Collection // Quartz counters anchor the open windowed kitchen met by a classic white ceramic subway tile backsplash + tiled floor // The sleek Bathroom not only has a window but also a convenient step-in shower // The bedroom has windows both South + West facing, allowing for wonderful cross ventilation // Many deep closets have been professionally outfitted which is a thoughtful addition // This move-in ready spot comes with the piece-of-mind of a skilled live-in Super // Enjoy on-site Laundry + Parking // Monthly of only $1103 per month includes: deductible taxes, heat, hot water + building maintenance // Easy commuting via the LIRR 2 blocks away, offering direct routes to Penn Station + Grand Central Madison // Lots of international cuisines are available from all the local restaurants + cafes, which also deliver directly to your door // Enjoy Great Neck South SD with access to the extensive Great Neck Parks with boating, ice skating, swimming, tennis, etc. // The culture, arts + entertainment featured in the area is world class offering seasonal events for every taste // So what are you waiting for? ...book your tour today:))

15 HILL PARK Avenue Unit #1-L, Great Neck Plaza

$450,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 935246 MLS
Welcome to your Manhattan perch — a sun-filled penthouse retreat in the heart of Morningside Heights. This rare HDFC co-op comes without income or resale restrictions, offering exceptional value. Perched atop a boutique pre-war building, this thoughtfully updated two-bedroom, one-bath home captures the warmth and character that define the neighborhood. Eastern and western exposures bathe the residence in consistent natural light, highlighting high ceilings, new flooring, and charming pre-war details throughout. The layout is practical and inviting, featuring a bright separate living room, a cheerful eat-in kitchen, and well-proportioned bedrooms with excellent storage. BA to verify sq footage. Sq footage is approximate. Virtually staged. 3115 Broadway is celebrated for its strong management and exceptionally low maintenance. Residents enjoy a live-in superintendent, upgraded laundry room, shared courtyard, bike storage, video intercom security, and a pet-friendly environment. Co-purchasing, guarantors, and subletting is permitted after two years. Located moments from Columbia University, Barnard College, and the Manhattan School of Music, the home offers effortless access to Riverside and Sakura Parks, beloved local cafés and restaurants, and convenient transportation via the 1 train and M4/M104 buses. Bright, comfortable, and full of character, this penthouse delivers standout value in one of Manhattan’s most cherished academic and cultural hubs — all for under $570K.

3115 Broadway Unit #61, New York (Manhattan)

$450,000
937385 MLS
Business for Sale: Lottus Event Center Prime Event Venue in Ridgewood, NY — Approximately 8,000 sq ft Nestled in the heart of Ridgewood at 6301 Fresh Pond Road, Lottus Event Center offers a rare opportunity to acquire a fully operating and beautifully designed event space with a strong reputation and steady clientele. This 8,000 sq ft multi-purpose venue currently hosts weddings, birthday celebrations, corporate events, and private parties. The space is modern, elegant, and flexible—easily customizable for a variety of themes and gatherings. Key Highlights Turnkey Operation: Fully furnished and operational—start earning from day one. Prime Location: High-visibility corner in a busy Ridgewood commercial district with strong foot traffic and excellent accessibility. Spacious Interior (8,000 sq ft): Open floor plan with high ceilings, dance floor, stage area, VIP seating, bridal room, and professional décor. Established Client Base: Bookings for weddings, sweet 16s, corporate functions, baby showers, and community events. Strong Revenue Potential: High demand for event spaces in NYC makes this an attractive business for both owner-operators and investors. Versatile Use: Can continue as an event venue or be adapted for a bar/lounge, performance hall, cultural center, studio, or other entertainment concepts. Ample Resources Included: Tables, chairs, lighting, sound equipment, bar setup, décor elements, and operating inventory. Why This Business Stands Out Event venues in New York City are consistently in demand, and Ridgewood’s rapid growth adds even more value. Lottus Event Center combines size, location, and reputation—making it an exceptional opportunity for anyone looking to enter or expand in the hospitality and events industry.

6301 Fresh Pond Road, Ridgewood

$414,500
3 Beds 1 Baths 933751 MLS
Live and Work, this place is set up for both -Prime Commercial/Industrial Investment Opportunity – Nearly 4 Usable Acres on Future I-86, with an additional 2 acres on the other side of the interstate, offering a good location for a future billboard opportunity. Attention investors and entrepreneurs: seize this rare opportunity to own nearly 6 acres in total of commercially zoned land with unbeatable visibility and strategic positioning. This property is situated directly on Route 17—soon to be redesignated as Interstate 86—and offers exceptional accessibility, perfectly positioned between both Route 17 and Old Route 17. Just under a mile from the highway entrance and less than 2 miles from Garnet Health Medical Center and the regional UPS distribution hub, this location places you at the heart of one of the Catskills’ most active and growing commercial corridors. This location is the future hotspot with warehouses on the drawing board in much of the surrounding area. Originally a residential 3-bedroom home, the building has been thoughtfully renovated and is now ideally suited for office use. The interior features stylish shiplap walls, a soaring cathedral ceiling, a spacious full bathroom, and three flexible rooms that are perfect for private offices, a conference space, or client meeting areas. A full basement with a garage provides excellent storage or expansion possibilities. Use the upstairs and rent the lower portion- Full Walkout Basement and Garage or use if for your own business. The property's expansive layout and level terrain offer endless potential: rent out the existing renovated office space for immediate income while developing an additional building on the ample open land. A generously sized parking lot provides convenience for both staff and visitors. With high visibility, proximity to key infrastructure, and room to expand, this is a standout investment opportunity for a visionary buyer. Commercial/industrial parcels of this size and location are becoming increasingly scarce—don't miss your chance to secure a foothold in a rapidly developing area. The billboard on the property will not be conveyed with the sale; this billboard faces Old Route 17~ Broker discloses interest*

1132 Old Route 17, Ferndale

$414,500
920697 MLS
Prime Commercial/Industrial Investment Opportunity – Nearly 4 Usable Acres on Future I-86, with an additional 2 acres on the other side of the interstate, offering a good location for a future billboard opportunity. Attention investors and entrepreneurs: seize this rare opportunity to own nearly 6 acres in total of commercially zoned land with unbeatable visibility and strategic positioning. This property is situated directly on Route 17—soon to be redesignated as Interstate 86—and offers exceptional accessibility, perfectly positioned between both Route 17 and Old Route 17. Just under a mile from the highway entrance and less than 2 miles from Garnet Health Medical Center and the regional UPS distribution hub, this location places you at the heart of one of the Catskills’ most active and growing commercial corridors. This location is the future hotspot with warehouses on the drawing board in much of the surrounding area. Originally a residential 3-bedroom home, the building has been thoughtfully renovated and is now ideally suited for office use. The interior features stylish shiplap walls, a soaring cathedral ceiling, a spacious full bathroom, and three flexible rooms that are perfect for private offices, a conference space, or client meeting areas. A full basement with a garage provides excellent storage or expansion possibilities. Use the upstairs and rent the lower portion- Full Walkout Basement and Garage to a landscaper or someone in need of extra storage space. The property's expansive layout and level terrain offer endless potential: rent out the existing renovated office space for immediate income while developing an additional building on the ample open land. A generously sized parking lot provides convenience for both staff and visitors. With high visibility, proximity to key infrastructure, and room to expand, this is a standout investment opportunity for a visionary buyer. Commercial/industrial parcels of this size and location are becoming increasingly scarce—don't miss your chance to secure a foothold in a rapidly developing area. The billboard on the property will not be conveyed with the sale; this billboard faces Old Route 17~ Broker discloses interest*

1132 Old Route 17, Ferndale

$429,000
930547 MLS
This upstate New York farm property in the village of Delhi, NY expresses the dream of rural living. With a feeling truly from another time, and yet a part of a vibrant Catskills culture, the property connects historic charm with modern community life. This one-of-a-kind, multi-use property offers spectacular architecture, rich earthy aromas, and classic greenhouses that creates sense of possibility and bounty. In the often fickle climate of the Catskills, the greenhouses provide a daily horticultural experience. Think unusual flora, dramatic succulents, flowing pageantries, and a perpetual potager that keeps meals diversified all year long. The main greenhouse, a classic Lord & Burnham glass structure measuring 76 by 25 feet, houses a prominent grape vine that winds through the space. At the far end of the atrium, a comfortable potting studio is heated by a wood stove. A second smaller Lord & Burnham greenhouse, modern hoop-style growing spaces, and numerous outdoor garden beds, including water-lily beds, add expansive options for horticulture projects. The 2-story building features impressive workspaces, a convenient half-bath, a dedicated private office, and a new glass-walled extension with a wood stove that functions as a four-season office or display room. Buyers can consider a public storefront or retain these areas for entrepreneurial projects. Upstairs, a spacious, modern 3-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers a fantastic live-work arrangement or a lucrative rental opportunity. The full, walkout basement houses modern utilities, including a coal-fired furnace, an oil-fired burner, and a root cellar that preserves harvest safely through winter. Sited on 1.4 acres, the property includes a carriage house that provides tool storage and a chicken coop from the Andrews estate that completes this noble setting. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise in Delhi, New York.

265 Main Street, Delhi

$429,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 930509 MLS
This upstate New York farm property in the village of Delhi, NY expresses the dream of rural living. With a feeling truly from another time, and yet a part of a vibrant Catskills culture, the property connects historic charm with modern community life. This one-of-a-kind, multi-use property offers spectacular architecture, rich earthy aromas, and classic greenhouses that creates sense of possibility and bounty. In the often fickle climate of the Catskills, the greenhouses provide a daily horticultural experience. Think unusual flora, dramatic succulents, flowing pageantries, and a perpetual potager that keeps meals diversified all year long. The main greenhouse, a classic Lord & Burnham glass structure measuring 76 by 25 feet, houses a prominent grape vine that winds through the space. At the far end of the atrium, a comfortable potting studio is heated by a wood stove. A second smaller Lord & Burnham greenhouse, modern hoop-style growing spaces, and numerous outdoor garden beds, including water-lily beds, add expansive options for horticulture projects. The 2-story building features impressive workspaces, a convenient half-bath, a dedicated private office, and a new glass-walled extension with a wood stove that functions as a four-season office or display room. Buyers can consider a public storefront or retain these areas for entrepreneurial projects. Upstairs, a spacious, modern 3-bedroom, 1-bath apartment offers a fantastic live-work arrangement or a lucrative rental opportunity. The full, walkout basement houses modern utilities, including a coal-fired furnace, an oil-fired burner, and a root cellar that preserves harvest safely through winter. Sited on 1.4 acres, the property includes a carriage house that provides tool storage and a chicken coop from the Andrews estate that completes this noble setting. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise in Delhi, New York.

265 Main Street, Delhi

$439,900
1 Beds 1 Baths 925010 MLS
Pre-War Charm Meets Modern Living in Prime Murray Hill! Welcome home to 139 East 30th Street, #3D, a beautifully situated one-bedroom co-op in the heart of Midtown South. Nestled on a quiet, tree-lined block in the coveted Murray Hill/Kips Bay area, this residence offers the perfect blend of classic New York architecture and contemporary convenience. Apartment Features: Spacious one-bedroom layout with a cozy, comfortable atmosphere. Located on the third floor of a charming pre-war building, offering a nice height and light. High ceilings and beautiful hardwood floors throughout (common for this building). Building & Neighborhood Highlights: The Andrada is an intimate, six-story, pre-war cooperative (built 1910) with only 23 units. Amenities: Enjoy the convenience of an elevator, live-in superintendent, central laundry room, and bike storage. Pet-Friendly: Furry friends are welcome! Investor/Flexible Ownership Friendly: Co-purchasing, guarantors, and pied-à-terre are permitted. Unbeatable Location: Experience a "Walker's and Rider's Paradise" with a Walk Score and Transit Score of 100! You are moments from the 6 train (28th & 33rd Streets) and a short walk to the N, Q, R, W lines and Grand Central Terminal. Local Charm: Steps away from excellent dining, chic bars, and essential services, including Trader Joe's and Fairway Market, and the tranquility of Madison Square Park. This is a rare opportunity to own a charming piece of Manhattan real estate in one of the city's most desirable and well-connected neighborhoods. Contact us today to schedule a private viewing!

139 E 30th Street Unit #3D, New York (Manhattan)

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.