Short answer: Pleasantville is a walkable village with a Metro-North station in the middle of town, a year-round Saturday farmers market and a tight-knit, small-town feel. Inventory is scarce, so homes sell based on what's competing with them right now, not last year's comps. Taxes also run higher than most buyers expect, especially inside the village line.

I moved to Pleasantville in 2018, and I've helped buyers and sellers here ever since. This guide covers what I tell clients over coffee: where the overlooked value is, how the village tax line works, which streets are a short walk to the train, and what's changing in town.

Key takeaways

  • Not every Pleasantville address pays village tax. Some homes near Pace University, on streets like Bear Ridge Road and Lakeshore Drive, are outside the village line and skip the village tax bill. They often aren't on public water and sewer.
  • Some streets are under five minutes from the train. Homes on parts of Washington, Manville, Bedford, Hobby, Pleasant and Sarles are an easy walk to the Metro-North station. Most commuters who drive park at Memorial Plaza.
  • Price to today's competition, not to comps. Well-priced homes go fast. Homes with "aspirational" prices sit.
  • Taxes surprise people. Village homes pay a separate village tax on top of school, town and county taxes.
  • The village is busier than it was. Traffic, parking and new construction have all grown in the last five years, and more projects are proposed.

In this guide: Why it's different · The village line · Walking to the train · How pricing really works · Saturday mornings · What's changing · Is it right for you? · FAQ

Pleasantville is not "just another Westchester suburb"

The most common mistake I see from buyers coming up from Manhattan or Brooklyn is assuming Pleasantville is interchangeable with every other town on the Harlem Line. It isn't. The village is compact and walkable. The train station, the shops on Wheeler Avenue and Memorial Plaza are all clustered together, and a lot of daily life happens on foot.

Wheeler Avenue in downtown Pleasantville, NY, on a winter evening
Wheeler Avenue in downtown Pleasantville on a winter evening.

That shapes the experience of living here. You'll know your barista, the people who run the shops you use, and your neighbors. It also shapes the market: when the right house comes up in the right location, a lot of buyers are competing for it at once.

The village line: the tax and utility trade-off most buyers miss

Buyers tend to focus on the streets close to the village center and the school campuses. Two pockets get overlooked, and they work very differently.

The other side of the Saw Mill. Pleasant Avenue, Sarles Lane and Mountain Road are on the far side of the Saw Mill River Parkway from the school campuses, so a lot of buyers skip them. They're still inside the village and pay village tax. You get village services and the same walkable access to town, often with less competition than on the school side.

Near Pace University. Homes on streets like Bear Ridge Road and Lakeshore Drive sit outside the Village of Pleasantville even though they have a Pleasantville address, so in some cases they don't pay village tax. The trade-off is that they often aren't connected to public water and sewer. That can mean a well and septic system, and you'll want those inspected. The upside is real, though: you can often get more house for less in annual property taxes.

A few things to know before you fall in love with a listing:

  • Village tax is a separate bill. Inside the village, the Village of Pleasantville bills its own tax, payable in two halves (due July 1 and December 31). School, town and county taxes are collected by the Town of Mount Pleasant.
  • Village services are separate from the town's. The village runs its own municipal services, which is part of what village residents pay for.
  • Check the school district, not just the mailing address. Pleasantville-addressed homes can fall in different school districts. Confirm the district on the tax bill or with the district before you make an offer.
  • Taxes run higher than most buyers expect. Ask for the actual tax bills, not an estimate. For village homes, that means the village bill plus the school, town and county bills.

Looking at homes in Pleasantville?

I'll help you sort out village vs. non-village homes, water and sewer, the school district and the real tax picture before you write an offer.

Search Pleasantville homesCall (914) 341-2998

Walking to the train: which streets are closest

Pleasantville's Metro-North station is on the Harlem Line, about 30 miles from Grand Central, right in the center of the village. For a lot of my clients, being able to walk to the train is the whole point of buying here.

From many homes on Washington Avenue, Pleasant Avenue, Sarles Lane, Manville Road, Bedford Road and Hobby Street, the walk to the platform can be under five minutes. Commuters who drive mostly park at Memorial Plaza, next to the station.

Memorial Plaza commuter parking lot next to the Pleasantville Metro-North station
The Memorial Plaza commuter lot, next to the Pleasantville Metro-North station.

My advice: walk it yourself at the time you'd actually leave in the morning. Then look up your train on the MTA TrainTime app, because peak and off-peak schedules differ quite a bit.

How pricing really works here: scarcity beats comps

The thing that surprises my Pleasantville sellers most is how completely this market runs on scarcity. Comparable sales from the last six months are a lagging indicator. What actually sets your price is what else is for sale the week you list, and how many buyers are waiting for a house like yours.

  • Well-priced homes sell immediately. When a house is priced against the current competition, buyers move fast. Pleasantville buyers know what they want and will pay for it.
  • Overpriced homes sit. An "aspirational" price can keep a house on the market for a long time, even when inventory is tight.
  • Timing is everything. The same house can perform very differently depending on what's listed next to it.

If you're thinking about selling, the useful question isn't "what did the house down the street get last spring?" It's "what will a buyer compare my house to this month?"

Thinking about selling in Pleasantville?

Get a price based on what you're competing with right now, not just last year's sales.

Get my Pleasantville home valueCall (914) 341-2998

Saturday mornings in Pleasantville

If you want to know whether you'd like living here, spend a Saturday morning in town. Here's how locals do it:

  • The farmers market at Memorial Plaza. It runs outdoors all year: Saturdays 8:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. from April through December, and 9:30 a.m. to noon from January through March. Note that it's a pet-free market.
  • Breakfast at the Pleasantville Diner, also on Memorial Plaza, across from the train station.
  • Coffee at The Black Cow on Wheeler Avenue.
  • Pastries and lattes at Jean-Jacques on Bedford Road.

What's changing in the village

There's been a lot of construction in Pleasantville over the past five years, since COVID, and more is planned. When I moved here in 2018, Memorial Plaza wasn't as packed, cars weren't sitting through two cycles of red lights, and parking wasn't as scarce. The biggest change I've seen is how much traffic and how many people there are now.

The Memorial Plaza and Manville Road intersection in Pleasantville, NY
The Memorial Plaza and Manville Road intersection, where traffic has picked up noticeably over the past five years.

What's on the table now:

  • More rentals and retail. There's continued interest in building luxury rentals and more retail space in and around the village.
  • The Campus Drive townhouse proposal. Lennar (US Home, LLC) has proposed townhomes on about 20 acres behind the Foxwood condominiums, on Campus Drive and Carey Court. It was first presented as 102 townhomes and was revised in 2026. As of this writing it's still going through village review, so check the village's Planning Commission and Village Board agendas for the latest.

For buyers, this means more choices over time, especially townhomes. It also means more cars and busier streets. For sellers, new construction becomes part of the competition your house is priced against.

Is Pleasantville right for you?

Pleasantville is charming, tight-knit and walkable, and it comes with trade-offs. You're paying for the school district, the community, the convenience and a small-town lifestyle that's hard to find this close to the city. You'll also feel it when inventory is tight, because prices here reflect demand.

If walkability, a village center and a real sense of community are at the top of your list, it's hard to beat. If you want more space or lower taxes, look at homes outside the village line, or at neighboring Thornwood, Briarcliff Manor and Chappaqua, and compare them side by side.

Pleasantville FAQ

Do all homes with a Pleasantville address pay village taxes?

No. Homes inside the Village of Pleasantville pay a village tax on top of school, town and county taxes. Some homes with a Pleasantville address, such as those near Pace University on Bear Ridge Road and Lakeshore Drive, are outside the village, and in those cases they don't pay village tax. Those homes often aren't on public water and sewer, so check for well and septic.

Where do Pleasantville commuters park for Metro-North?

Most commuters who drive park at Memorial Plaza, next to the Pleasantville station on the Harlem Line. Many homes on Washington Avenue, Pleasant Avenue, Sarles Lane, Manville Road, Bedford Road and Hobby Street are within about a five-minute walk of the train.

How are homes priced in Pleasantville?

Mostly by current competition. Inventory is scarce, so past comparable sales lag the market. Homes priced against what's for sale now tend to sell quickly, while overpriced homes can sit for a long time.

When is the Pleasantville Farmers Market?

Every Saturday at Memorial Plaza, all year: 8:30 a.m. to 1 p.m. from April through December, and 9:30 a.m. to noon from January through March.

Talk to someone who lives here

Whether you're buying your first home in the village or selling the home you've lived in for years, I'm happy to walk through it with you, no pressure.

Call Steve: (914) 341-2998See the Pleasantville market report

Sources: Village of Pleasantville: when village, town and school taxes are due · Village of Pleasantville Assessor's Office · Pleasantville Farmers Market · MTA Harlem Line schedules · The Examiner News coverage of the Campus Drive proposal. Tax, school district and utility details vary by property; verify them for any specific home.

Stephen Zondorak, Licensed Real Estate Broker, Astor Lane RealtyWritten by Stephen Zondorak
Licensed Real Estate Broker and broker of Astor Lane Realty · NYS License #10311207710
531 Central Park Ave, Suite 305-B, Scarsdale, NY · (914) 341-2998
Find Stephen on Zillow, Homes.com, RateMyAgent, Facebook and Instagram.